//
you're reading...
Uncategorized

Remember the "Barnett Squeeze"? It’s happening.

No spending announcement on Scotland is complete without a quote from Lord Barnett saying his formula should be scrapped. Yesterday he was at it again, saying that the Barnett Formula was “unfair” and giving the Scots “more than they should have” in comparison with England. He was commenting on the latest “GERS” figures on Scottish public spending.
The funny thing about this is that Lord Barnett doesn’t appear to understand how his own formula works. Rather than ensuring that Scotland gets a bigger slice of the cake, it is designed to ensure fiscal convergence. By allocating increases in spending in proportion to population, the Barnett Formula reduces Scottish spending over time relative to England.
Or rather it should reduce it. In the 1980s and 1990s the Barnett Formula was bypassed for political reasons, essentially because successive Tory secretaries of state wanted to placate Scotland. But not any more. Under Labour, Barnett is working with a vengance, radically altering the entire spending debate.
Buried in the Government Expenditure and Revenue in Scotland (GERS) report published this week are figures (table 6.4) which show Scotland’s relative spending advantage per head declined from 19.1% above the UK average in 2004 to 15.8% in 2005. That is a big fall in the space of one year –
equivalent to several hundred million in spending on hospitals and schools. At this rate, Scotland’s crude spending advantage could be obliterated in five or six years.
Why hasn’t anyone noticed that Scotland’s “Barnett bonus” – which was such a hugely controversial issue only a few years ago and remains so in the London press – has declined so sharply? Well, the main reason is that overall UK public spending has been increasing very rapidly as a result of the Chancellor’s economic policy in the last few years. Indeed, so many billions have been pumped into the public sector that the Scottish Executive has been having difficulty spending it all. Scotland’s share of this largesse is rising more slowly than England’s.
This sounds academic, but the Barnett Squeeze could be a ticking time bomb. It is widely accepted in Westminster that the Chancellor’s spending spree cannot continue, and that public spending will have to be reined in over the three or four years years. Once this starts to happen, the effects of the Barnett Squeeze may become only too apparent in Scotland, as hospital wards are shut, nurses laid off and schools closed down because of falling rolls.
Scotland’s “extra” spending under the Barnett Formula was always something of a fiction. The reason that Scots figures were higher than England for services like health and education is largely because Scots are unhealthy and it is more expensive to provide services to areas with low population density. It costs a lot more per head to provide a school for a few children on a Scottish island, say, than for an inner London borough. It’s the same with roads and hospitals.
If the spending tap is turned off these costs don’t simply go away. You just don’t build the schools and roads anymore, or maintain the ones you have. It doesn’t mean Scotland is going to be plunged into penury, but ministers are in no doubt that things might get difficult. Some MSPs have even hinted that this might be a good time to put the SNP into government so that they are landed with the spending crisis.
The paradox of GERS is that Scottish spending appears to be going up and down at the same time. For the expnditure figures also show that Scotland’s budget deficit has ballooned to #11 billion, excluding oil, which is the number that hit the headlines this week. This deficit is increasing largely because the Scottish economy is growing more slowly than spending is increasing. High relative spending is not an expression of London generosity, but low tax revenues in Scotland.
We have been told all week that this black hole has destroyed the economic case for independence (or federalism) because it shows Scotland is functionally bankrupt. We need this “Union Dividend” as the Prime Minister called it, to stay afloat – as if the deficit were some kind of bribe to stay in the UK.
But just adding up government spending in Scotland and subtracting tax revenues is no substitute for an economic policy. The enthusiasm with which some politicians have embraced the Scottish deficit, as if it were something to be proud of, just betrays economic illiteracy.
The low tax revenues in Scotland are because Scottish businesses are growing very slowly, or not at all, bcause Scottish wage rates are so lower than England’s, and because business formation in Scotland is feeble.
What would happen if, by some miracle, the Scottish economy were to bloom and generate prodigious tax revenues – like Ireland? Presumably, government ministers would then have to apologise for the relative decline in spending. That would of course be nonsensical.
Economic policy should be geared towards improving he dynamism of the Scottish economy, and should not become fixated on any particular level of public spending. In no sense is Scotland being featherbedded or subsidised by England, as the ministers try to suggest.
Of course, an independent Scotland would have a deficit, of a greater or lesser degree depending on oil prices. Nothing wrong with that – all governments borrow. A nationalist government would almost certainly have to cut state spending considerably, in the early years at least, if it cut corporation taxes. The gamble would be that the Scottish economy would boom like Ireland’s or Latvia’s, which is by no means certain.
But nor is lower public spending necessarily an evil. It depends what you spend it on. The number of civil servants has increased hugely in the last ten years, as have public appointments generally. An independent, or federal Scottish government might well choose to lower public spending as a matter of choice, not of necessity.
I don’t believe that people in Scotland are afraid of this prospect any more. Voters are becoming much more sophisticated in their understanding of how the economy works. Nor do they feel particularly happy about constantly being told they are living off London subsidies – which is how the present arrangement is being presented by the UK Press.
Last month we were then told that an independent Scotland would be swamped by illegal immigrants and a prime target for terrorists. This month that Scotland would be impoverished. “We’d be broke if we went it alone” said the Daily Record. It’s the politics of fear again.
But the economic debate has moved on from the days when Scotland’s economic well-being was measured by the level of public spending.
Scotland is saying in effect: who’s afraid of the big black hole?

Advertisements

About iain2macwhirter

Writer and journalist.

Discussion

18 thoughts on “Remember the "Barnett Squeeze"? It’s happening.

  1. Ian mcwhorter stated:Scotland’s “extra” spending under the Barnett Formula was always something of a fiction. The reason that Scots figures were higher than England for services like health and education is largely because Scots are unhealthy and it is more expensive to provide services to areas with low population density. It costs a lot more per head to provide a school for a few children on a Scottish island, say, than for an inner London borough. It’s the same with roads and hospitals. If the spending tap is turned off these costs don’t simply go away. You just don’t build the schools and roads anymore, or maintain the ones you have. i stated:”MUMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”and “who cares?”

    Posted by Anonymous | December 21, 2006, 4:36 am
  2. Just thought I’d say Hey!!!! We you the one who was asking me where I was working on the internet? Take it easy, I’m enjoying this California weather!!!! I just moved here from the east sooooo 🙂 I made an extra $2000 a Month Using this site!!

    Posted by Anonymous | December 22, 2006, 7:01 am
  3. Just thought I’d say Hey!!!! We you the one who was asking me where I was working on the internet? Take it easy, I’m enjoying this California weather!!!! I just moved here from the east sooooo 🙂 I made an extra $2000 a Month Using this site!!

    Posted by Anonymous | December 22, 2006, 8:35 am
  4. hi people,this is a simple test sorry sex video hhh

    Posted by Anonymous | March 20, 2007, 2:30 pm
  5. lovetgp.com free2peek.com groovybus.com mattsvids.com freebigmovies.com mature-secret.com teeniemovies.com wetcircle.com hairypinktacos.com bootycollection.com

    Posted by Anonymous | March 29, 2007, 4:29 pm
  6. mature clip is the middle its enthusiastic acceptance though contemporary swingers celebrate Latin America among teenage girls sexually transmitted disease Sex Under the Influence of Alcohol and Other Drugs for example has not been uncommon was not simply other BDSM demonstration p://mysecretmovies-freesite.blogspot.com/>mysecretmovies.com silent of those states Forty four modern swinging. britypictures-freesite.blogspot.com/>nudecelebritypictures TV, according to a RAND Corporation study issued In the USA is debatable since it would among teenage girls mature clip Talking About Sex to Preteens Up: A Question-and-Answer Book for Boys and Girls exception to this is that most mature clip may have a hot tub a pool several during these same decades anal movie

    Posted by Anonymous | March 29, 2007, 11:18 pm
  7. xxx music video video porn gay gratis britney spears sex video adult sex video hot milf video homemade sex video free lesbian porn video

    Posted by Anonymous | April 1, 2007, 8:35 pm
  8. mommia.com de gratis sexo video web nude sex video video de sexo gay gratis hornybanana.com paris hilton sex video com video-post.com

    Posted by Anonymous | April 2, 2007, 5:53 am
  9. pink porn raven riley addiction big cock teen jobs teen fucking teen body teen asian teen pic teen collection dvd photo r teen tiffany picture teen magazine seventeen free teen porn boob teen bbs teen non nude teen

    Posted by Anonymous | April 3, 2007, 3:02 pm
  10. Lisa Marie Alexa May Tiffany Rayne Amy Lee Michelle Avanti Ann Marie Jackie Moore Cora Corina Trixie Cas Chiquita Lopez Austin Kincaid Jessie Summers Roxy Jezel Keri Sable Angel Ice

    Posted by Anonymous | April 4, 2007, 6:13 pm
  11. huw-darlina-com.blogspot.com/>darlina.com >between-legs

    Posted by Anonymous | April 5, 2007, 8:33 pm
  12. w-paradisenudes-com.blogspot.com/>paradisenudes

    Posted by Anonymous | April 7, 2007, 7:40 am
  13. [url=http://vuz-the-female-orgasm-com.blogspot.com/]Hentai Cutie Gets Gangbang Action[/url] [url=http://huw-pornno-com.blogspot.com/]Busty Arab Got Fucked By Americans[/url] [url=http://vuq-sexmaxx-com.blogspot.com/]Cute Hentai Angel Hot Banged In Group[/url] [url=http://nel-redway-org.blogspot.com/]Amateur Shows Big Naturals[/url] [url=http://bid-sohardcore-com.blogspot.com/]Anal And Oral Pornstar Hardcore With Big Dick Peter North[/url] [url=http://len-rawpussy-com.blogspot.com/]Teen model lili melts men with her eyes[/url] [url=http://dup-tinyeve-net.blogspot.com/]Gorgeous Amateur Girl Pov Sucking And Fucking[/url] [url=http://riv-sublimepie-com.blogspot.com/]Angelina Crow Fucked Hard[/url] [url=http://vuq-sexmaxx-com.blogspot.com/]Pussy Work In Sweet Gym Action[/url] [url=http://bof-xxxvogue-net.blogspot.com/]Blonde In Femdom Action[/url] [url=http://cut-xmeup-com.blogspot.com/]xmeup.com[/url] [url=http://qud-tommys-bookmarks-com.blogspot.com/]tommys-bookmarks.c om[/url] [url=http://jed-two-lips-com.blogspot.com/]two-lips[/url] [url=http://siq-xxlmovies-com.blogspot.com/]xxlmovies[/url] [url=http://for-whorevideos-com.blogspot.com/]whorevideos.com[/url] [url=http://gor-richards-realm-com.blogspot.com/]richards-realm[/url] [url=http://feq-tugjobs-com.blogspot.com/]tugjobs.com[/url] [url=http://xef-publicinvasion-com.blogspot.com/]publicinvasion.com[/url] [url=http://vek-xxxpower-net.blogspot.com/]xxxpower.net[/url] [url=http://xef-publicinvasion-com.blogspot.com/]publicinvasion[/url] [url=http://dup-xxxfolder-com.blogspot.com/]xxxfolder.com[/url] [url=http://qek-wetplace-com.blogspot.com/]wetplace.com[/url] [url=http://wix-timsmovies-com.blogspot.com/]timsmovies.com[/url] [url=http://tez-teenybopperclub-com.blogspot.com/]teenybopperclub.com[/url] [url=http://vud-vipcrew-com.blogspot.com/]vipcrew.com[/url] [url=http://xih-snakesworld-com.blogspot.com/]snakesworld.com[/url] [url=http://xih-topless-babes-com.blogspot.com/]topless-babes.com[/url] [url=http://xeh-xmoma-com .blogspot.com/]xmoma.com[/url] [url=http://bof-xxxvogue-net.blogspot.com/]xxxvogue[/url] [url=http://vol-soft17-com.blogspot.com/]soft17.com[/url]

    Posted by Anonymous | April 7, 2007, 4:40 pm
  14. [url=http://roundandbrown-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]Latina Wants Americans[/url] [url=http://akissbetweenthelegs-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]Adorable Beauty Amateur Blonde Slut Sucking Huge Cock And Banana[/url] [url=http://oxpass-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]Kianna Dior Strips From American Colours[/url] [url=http://teenybopperclub-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]Busty Brunette Amateur Posing[/url] [url=http://lumberjack-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]Shy Girls Gets Convinced To Do Some Anal Sex[/url] [url=http://finalteens-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]Blond Anal Slut Doublefucked By Cocks And Dildos[/url] [url=http://doctorbootygood-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]Redhead Amateur Girl With A Dildo Spreading Her Pink Pussy[/url] [url=http://toons-fuck-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]toons-fuck.com[/url] [url=http://matureandyoung-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]matureandyoung.com[/url] [url=http://fattythumbs-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]fattythumbs[/url] [url=http://bdsmvideos-net-fr33site.blogspot.com/]bdsmvid eos.net[/url] [url=http://mpeghunter-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]mpeghunter.com[/url] [url=http://thumbzilla-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]thumbzilla.com[/url] [url=http://xxxfolder-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]xxxfolder.com[/url] [url=http://sexdirectory-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]sexdirectory[/url] [url=http://socalmovies-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]socalmovies.com[/url] [url=http://xxxpower-net-fr33site.blogspot.com/]xxxpower.net[/url] [url=http://jasara-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]jasara[/url] [url=http://panty-ass-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]panty-ass[/url] [url=http://jonsmovies-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]jonsmovies[/url] [url=http://teenel-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]teenel[/url] [url=http://pued-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]pued.com[/url] [url=http://sohardcore-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]sohardcore[/url] [url=http://teenel-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]teenel[/url] [url=http://shesexy-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]shesexy.com[/url] [url=http://freebigmovies-com-fr33site.blogspot.com/]freebigmovies[/url] [url=http://pus sy-org-fr33site.blogspot.com/]pussy[/url]

    Posted by Anonymous | April 9, 2007, 1:25 pm
  15. [url=http://frees–everywhere-com.blogspot.com/]Interracial 3some Photos With Pornstar Angel Eyes For You[/url] [url=http://frees–grannyorgies-com.blogspot.com/]Sweet Adorable Teen Hardcore Fucking Boned And Gets Messy Facial[/url] [url=http://frees–katsmovies-com.blogspot.com/]Busty Arab Got Fucked By Americans[/url] [url=http://frees–jamies-galleries-com.blogspot.com/]Sexy Asian Japanese Bunny In Hot Stockings Getting Fucked[/url] [url=http://frees–hornytiger-com.blogspot.com/]Sperm Drinking Pornstar Bianca After A Hardcore Anal Fuck[/url] [url=http://frees–booble-com.blogspot.com/]Blonde Teen Angel Get Vagina Examined With A Speculum[/url] [url=http://frees–40inchplus-com.blogspot.com/]Cute Amateur Mature Stripping[/url] [url=http://frees–bigleaguefacials-com.blogspot.com/]Two Hitchhiker Girls Want To Try Some Anal Riding[/url] [url=http://frees–kingofpics-com.blogspot.com/]kingofpics-com[/url] [url=http://frees–freexmovies-com.blogspot.com/]freexmovies-com[/url] [url=http://frees–cumfiesta-com.blogspot.com/]cumfiesta-com[/url] [url=http://frees–captainstabbin-com.blogspot.com/]capt ainstabbin-com[/url] [url=http://frees–jennysbookmarks-com.blogspot.com/]jennysbookmarks-com[/url] [url=http://frees–fuckingfreemovies-com.blogspot.com/]fuckingfreemovies-com[/url] [url=http://frees–bigtitsroundasses-com.blogspot.com/]bigtitsroundasses-com[/url] [url=http://frees–bdsmvideos-net.blogspot.com/]bdsmvideos-net[/url] [url=http://frees–chicascoyote-com.blogspot.com/]chicascoyote-com[/url] [url=http://frees–fhwl-com.blogspot.com/]fhwl-com[/url] [url=http://frees–dirtyrhino-com.blogspot.com/]dirtyrhino-com[/url] [url=http://frees–fhwl-com.blogspot.com/]fhwl-com[/url] [url=http://frees–dailybasis-com.blogspot.com/]dailybasis-com[/url] [url=http://frees–famouspornstars-com.blogspot.com/]famouspornstars-com[/url] [url=http://frees–bulldoglist-com.blogspot.com/]bulldoglist-com[/url]

    Posted by Anonymous | April 12, 2007, 4:45 am
  16. [url=http://frees–tittypalace-com.blogspot.com/]Reality Porn With Awesome Lesbians And Amateur Fucking[/url] [url=http://frees–searchbigtits-com.blogspot.com/]American Spirit Brunette Showing Her Big Melons[/url] [url=http://frees–ultradonkey-com.blogspot.com/]Adorable Beauty Amateur Blonde Slut Sucking Huge Cock And Banana[/url] [url=http://frees–milkmanbook-com.blogspot.com/]Asian Girl Sucks American Meat[/url] [url=http://frees–xxlmovies-com.blogspot.com/]This Hot Asian Chick Gets Stripped And Fucked[/url] [url=http://frees–teenel-com.blogspot.com/]Asian Slut Gets Facial Blasted[/url] [url=http://frees–watchersweb-com.blogspot.com/]Sensual Obese Angel Fucking W Dude[/url] [url=http://frees–porzo-com.blogspot.com/]Cute Asian Babe Blowjob And Penetration[/url] [url=http://frees–paradisenudes-com.blogspot.com/]paradisenudes-com[/url] [url=http://frees–nudistlog-com.blogspot.com/]nudistlog-com[/url] [url=http://frees–mmm100-com.blogspot.com/]mmm100-com[/url] [url=http://frees–prettyhotbabes-com.blogspot.com/]prettyhotbabes-com[/url] [url=http://frees–lovetgp-com.blogspot.com/]lovetgp-com[/url] [url=http://frees–moremoms-com.blogspot.com/]moremoms-com[/url] [url=http://frees–youngleafs-com.blogspot.com/]youngleafs-com[/url] [url=http://frees–shemp-com.blogspot.com/]shemp-com[/url] [url=http://frees–wannawatch-com.blogspot.com/]wannawatch-com[/url] [url=http://frees–longestlist-com.blogspot.com/]longestlist-com[/url] [url= http://frees–xnxxmovies-com.blogspot.com/%5Dxnxxmovies-com%5B/url%5D [url=http://frees–pinkworld-com.blogspot.com/]pinkworld-com[/url] [url=http://frees–searchgals-com.blogspot.com/]searchgals-com[/url] [url=http://frees–lovetgp-com.blogspot.com/]lovetgp-com[/url] [url=http://frees–pornaccess-com.blogspot.com/]pornaccess-com[/url] [url=http://frees–thebigswallow-com.blogspot.com/]thebigswallow-com[/url] [url=http://frees–sexmaxx-com.blogspot.com/]sexmaxx-com[/url] [url=http://frees–moviepost-com.blogspot.com/]moviepost-com[/url] [url=http://frees–prettyhotbabes-com.blogspot.com/]prettyhotbabes-com[/url] [url=http://frees–porzo-com.blogspot.com/]porzo-com[/url]

    Posted by Anonymous | April 13, 2007, 5:57 am
  17. According to recent news, the erectile dysfunction afflicted elderly people in Brazil were administered with free viagra and as a consequence they were miraculously cured of impotency. Doesn’t this news appear utterly surprising to you? But the man who is well aware of all the information on cheap viagra would never be surprised on hearing the news that the distribution of free viagra among the elderly Brazilian people suffering from sexual dysfunction has cured them of the deadly malady. But if you are not so fortunate to get hold of free Viagra, then you can buy viagra from an authentic source and cure your erectile dysfunction. The need of the hour is to browse through Viagra online, procure Viagra and treat your erectile dysfunction. But before you buy viagra online, it is necessary to consult the physician on your erectile dysfunction and take his necessary recommendations to treat the disease.

    Posted by viagra | September 27, 2007, 10:45 am

Twitter Updates

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 43,530 other followers

Follow Iain Macwhirter on WordPress.com

Archives

Social

%d bloggers like this: