you're reading...
Politics. Scotland Bill. tax powers. Calman. Alex Salmond. independence. tartan tax.

Calman tax powers are a milestone to Scottish independence, not a millstone for Holyrood.

If there was a twinkle in the eye of Alex Salmond last week, as he scoffed at the new tax powers being offered in the Scotland Bill , it may be because, under the table, he was pinching himself.   I’m pinching myself.  I still can’t quite believe that a Tory-led coalition government in London is introducing the widest and deepest extension of Scottish constitutional powers since devolution, even if they are flawed. 

 The new Scotland Bill, and its curious fifty-fifty income tax division,  was greeted with howls of protest at unionist perfidy:  not enough! the wrong kind of tax! deflationary! Scotland will lose out!  But this misses the point. Dismantling the Barnett apparatus and ending Scotland’s fiscal dependency was never going to happen over night.  It will be a process of negotiation and compromise. Only a minority of Scots ever wanted full fiscal separation, or independence, and a lot fewer do following the 2008 financial crash.  The SNP more or less accept this now, which is why they unceremoniously dumped the independence referendum bill, rather than have the indignity of seeing it mauled in the Scottish parliament.  

  And the truth is that what has happened this week is in line with the long term Nationalist game plan.  It is a significant incremental extension of the Scottish parliament’s powers in a way that can only imply further autonomy in future.   Hardly has the ink dried on the Scotland Bill than the debate has begun about what happens next.  And notice that some of the most trenchant criticisms have come not from the Nationalists, but from businessmen like Ben Thompson of Reform Scotland who want the tax powers extended. Changed days. 

       The SNP win even when they lose.  Just when the steam had gone from the independence debate, with the SNP facing defeat in May, along comes the Coalition to keep the constitutional pot boiling nicely. At the very least, by accepting the moral and economic case for tax raising powers for the Scottish Parliament, the unionist parties have opened the biggest can of fiscal worms since the creation of the Barnett Formula.   There’s enough here to keep columnists like me in business for decades. I almost wonder if the LibDems intentionally devised this rickety compromise in order to hasten the progress toward federal tax sharing.   I’m not a tax expert, but Scotland is getting a half way house on income tax which is certainly looks half baked,.  And even I can see that it’s only be a matter of time before it’s extended. 

   The UK government has accepted that the new tax regime must be revenue neutral for the next decade or so – in other words,  Scotland must not be seen to lose out on what it might have received had the Barnett Formula still been in operation.   Well, ten years is a long time – easily long enough to refashion this settlement.   The UK government has further accepted that the Scottish parliament should have borrowing powers to accompany the taxes it raises.  This is only reasonable.  When there is an economic downturn, tax revenues slump, as we have seen in the last two years, and governments have to compensate by borrowing to keep economic activity up.  The Scotland Bill is offering £2.7bn – which is being derided as not enough, wrong kind of borrowing, unionist trap etc..  But again, I am pinching myself in disbelief that the UK Treasury  and the Bank of England have conceded this at all, because it could lead to the creation of a Scottish National Debt.  In future, were a Scottish government to argue convincingly for extending responsible borrowing beyond these arbitrary limits, I don’t see how the UK could reasonably refuse it.

   Of course, there is no oil fund or share of hydrocarbon taxes.   That was always the most serious omission from the Calman Commission’s.   Scotland remains the only region, principality, state or nation in the world to have discovered oil and received no direct benefit from it. Nor will the Scottish parliament be able to vary VAT or corporation tax.  The Scottish government rightly argues that a region like Scotland, with chronic low growth, needs business taxation to reverse the tendency for capital and skilled employees to migrate south.    But remember, the EU is pressing Ireland to give up its low corporation taxes on the grounds that “fiscal dumping” as it is called, is incompatible with membership of the union.  Brussels may bar corporation tax, not London 

     If the Scottish government (and thanks to the Scotland Bill it is now officially recognised as a government) sets up the apparatus of a Scottish treasury, and attracts some clever people to work in it, I suspect they could  mount a convincing case that oil and aspects of business taxation cannot be left out of account indefinitely.   This week’s bill allows Scotland to create new taxes on top of stamp duty on homes. (Aye, but they’ll all be the wrong new taxes, not enough new taxes, unionist plot etc…)    In theory, Holyrood could seek to develop its own tax base – and not just a plastic bags tax, but local sales taxes, tourist tax or any number of revenue raisers.  It could even restore the 18th Century window tax – though I suspect this might meet with some resistance. 

    Mind you, in creating new taxes, the Scottish parliament will have to answer to the Scottish people, who may not be very keen on paying them.  And here’s the rub.  The challenge this bill poses is for the Scottish Parliament not only to be offered fiscal responsibility but to take it.  Holyrood will now have to vote regularly on whether or not to vary its new taxes.  It may be that the Scottish parties will choose not to use them at all, just as they have declined to use the parliament’s existing tax raising powers.  But that would be feeble and hypocritical: Holyrood politicians can’t go on blaming London cuts when they have the means to counter them at home. 

  No, this is not going to be as easy as meekly accepting Barnett handouts. Scotland has to learn to walk, fiscally speaking, before it can run.  Calman is baby steps, certainly, and may cause Holyrood to stagger about a bit before it find its feet.  But one it is up and running, I can’t see what will stop it. 

About @iainmacwhirter

I'm a columnist for the Herald. Author of "Road to Referendum" and "Disunited Kingdom". Was a BBC TV and radio presenter for 25 years - "Westminster Live" and "Holyrood Live" mainly. Spent time as columnist for The Observer, Guardian, New Statesman. Former Rector of Edinburgh University. Live in Edinburgh and spend a lot of time in the French Pyrenees. Will that do?


7 thoughts on “Calman tax powers are a milestone to Scottish independence, not a millstone for Holyrood.

  1. "In future, were a Scottish government to argue convincingly for extending responsible borrowing beyond these arbitrary limits, I don’t see how the UK could reasonably refuse it."That's right, Iain. But since when was Westminster's attitude to Holyrood constrained by reason?

    Posted by voiceofourown | December 10, 2010, 2:30 pm
  2. Also, if Calman wasn't a unionist plot, wtf was it?All parties involved were unionist, 2 of the 3 political parties involved had offered NO extension of devolution in their manifestos, the option of independence was to be excluded from consideration, the report states that part of its purpose was to strengthen Scotland's place in the union…. need I go on Iain?

    Posted by voiceofourown | December 10, 2010, 2:41 pm
  3. [url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]Cheap Generic Viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap cialis generic levitra viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap kamagra generic viagra videos[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic india viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]generic cheap viagra licensed pharmacies[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]find buy cheap viagra search generic[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]viagra find buy cheap search generic[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic viagra without prescription[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic overnight viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic viagra deals[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]generic cheap viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic viagra usa[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap online generic viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]buy viagra cheap generic[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]generic viagra cheap[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic viagra no prescription[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap india generic viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]3 cheap generic substitute viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]caverta cheap cialis generic viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic buy viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic substitute viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap viagra generic[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]generic viagra discount cheap[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]generic viagra caverta cialis cheap[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]q cheap viagra generic lowest pri[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]generic viagra cialis levitra cheap[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]viagra cheap generic[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap foreign generic viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]buy generic viagra cheap[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]viagra generic cheap[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]buy cheap generic viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]generic viagra cheap no prescription[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]canadian pharmacy cheap generic viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap viagra search generic[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]buy cheap cialis generic levitra viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic viagra from india[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap canadian generic viagra[/url][url=http://cheapgenericviagra1.wordpress.com]cheap generic viagra online[/url]

    Posted by Anonymous | December 12, 2010, 1:04 am
  4. Very much liking the tenor and content of Iain's pieces recently, especially this one. One doesn't have to agree with all of the conclusions to appreciate the effort to contribute to the debate and to elevate the level onto a 'politological' plane that has been sadly lacking from the three parties at Holyrood, that, on the topic of Iain's other peice on tutition fees, are united in wanting a graduate contribution. Where I part company with you Iain is that there should be some ire reserved for the feeble Scottish Labour response which is tantamount to an endorsement of fees, utterly abandoning any remaining pretence that the party will fight for egalitarian principles, instead offering the people of Scotland a counsel of despair (i.e. it is inevitable) – the tories of course are not really worthy of mention at all. Also worth looking at is Joyce Macmillan's piece in yesterday's Scotsman (17 Dec) on the same topic.

    Posted by Wee Fifer | December 18, 2010, 11:52 am
  5. what I was looking for, thanks

    Posted by Anonymous | January 7, 2011, 11:31 am
  6. [url=http://remroom.ru]ремонт квартир cвоими руками[/url] Улучшение и отделка помещений, комнат или дач – это одна из актуальных в настоящее время проблема большинства людей, решившихся, наконец, привести в порядок свой дом. Мало того, что улучшение – это процесс трудоемкий и напряженный, еще и найти заслуживающую доверия компанию, занимающуюся отделкой комнат или домов сейчас почти нельзя. Дело в том, что все меньше и меньше в Москве существует компаний, делающих свою работу качественно, эффективно и недорого. [url=http://remroom.ru]ремонт новой квартиры[/url] Однако наша компания является приятным исключением из этого неприятного правила. Мы вот уже несколько лет занимается ремонтом офисов, комнат, домов и еще ни разу нам не приходило от наших клиентов ни неприятных отзывов, ни каких-либо жалоб. [url=http://remroom.ru]ремонт квартиры серии[/url] Большой опыт наших специалистов, а также высокий профессионализм всех без исключения наших работников, поможет сделать хорошо, качественно и – главное – доступно как косметический, так и капитальный ремонт. [url=http://remroom.ru]ремонт квартир видео[/url] Современное оборудование, новые технологии планировки и дизайна, а также индивидуальный подход к каждому клиенту и гибкая система скидок сделали нашу компанию самой успешной на сегодня организацией, оказывающей услуги реставрации и отделке помещений, квартир или дач. [url=http://remroom.ru]ремонт квартир частный[/url]

    Posted by Anonymous | July 12, 2011, 2:25 pm
  7. how to unlock iphone 4unlock iphone 4unlock iphone 4 http://weeklyseven.com/news/2011/march/31/open-secret http://www.modmomsclub.com/content/3-tips-healthier-happy-holiday-season I put music from itunes on the really slow home computer onto CDs and want to put those CDs on my laptop.My laptop also has itunes. But the home computer is almost 7 years old. We think it runs so slowly b/c it has so much junk clogging up the hard drive. But it is possible it could have a virus that my parents don't know about. If I put the CDs onto my laptop, could it get infected with a virus? iphone 4 unlock unlock iphone 4 how to unlock iphone 4 [url=http://unlockiphone44.com]how to unlock iphone 4[/url] iphone 4 unlock unlock iphone 4

    Posted by Anonymous | August 6, 2011, 1:21 pm

Twitter Updates

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 57,082 other followers

Follow Iain Macwhirter on WordPress.com



%d bloggers like this: