you're reading...
2013, coronary heart disease, New Year, positive., scotland

Scottish hearts are getting better. About time.

2013 is supposed to be the year of the positive in Scotland, and for all the negativity that saturates coverage of Scottish affairs there is a lot to be positive about. 
One neglected statistic that caught my eye recently was that, in Scotland, deaths from coronary heart disease have fallen by 43% in ten years. The standardised death rate from stroke is also down 42%. Given Scotland’s problems of the heart this is a considerable, if largely unacknowledged achievement. Yes, 8,000 Scots still die from heart disease and we still have the worst coronary rate in Europe, but the fact that fewer people are dying from it is surely a cause for mild celebration. Especially in a year in which the dying Scotsman has become a staple joke on programmes like Have I Got News For You.
Outside the parliamentary constituencies in and around Glasgow, Scotland is almost as healthy as England. Heart disease is a very west coast phenomenon. But the good news here is that it is in Glasgow that the biggest falls in mortality have been recorded – a 10% drop in heart deaths in a year. For my money, that’s one of the best pieces of news that’s come out of the city in the last twenty years.
The improvement is down to a combination of factors: enlightened public policy – the smoking ban in 2005; improvements in medical care – we have some of the best heart surgeons in Europe; a decade of health promotion; and, most importantly, a conscious decision by many Scots to stay alive. All those people out running and cycling. It shows that people really can change, even in Scotland, and in a surprisingly short time. It’s not entirely clear why this change of heart has happened, but the existence of the Scottish parliament certainly helped to alter the climate of passivity and neglect that had allowed Scotland’s health problems to go unchecked for four decades.
Another factor is the decline in drinking, especially among men. Bet you didn’t realise that Scotland is going on the wagon, but according to the 2011 Scottish government health survey,  The number of Scottish adults drinking more than recommended limits has fallen by a quarter in the last ten years, from 28% to 21%.  Mean weekly consumption among men has declined from 20 units to 15.     That’s a very real change, but one which has had almost zero publicity. Nor has the fact that Scots, especially women, in upper income groups are nearly twice as likely to be problem drinkers than people in the lower income groups. So much for the popular image, peddled by soap operas like “Shameless”, that the poor spend all their money on drink. 
I’m not making this up. It’s all on the web. But I bet if you asked the average man or woman in the street, or the average MP in Westminster, they would tell you that just living in Scotland is seriously bad for your health, that lack of exercise and bad diet are sending us to an early grave, and that young people here are brought up on a combination of Buckfast and skunk weed. In fact young people especially seem to be turning away from alcohol and drugs. The numbers of under fifteen year olds taking drink or drugs once a week has fallen by a third in ten years, and the numbers taking cannabis has halved.

What seems to be happening is that the booze generation – the people who were lured early into heavy drinking by the promotion of alcopops in the 1990s – are now suffering the consequences,  in the rise of drink-related illnesses. Heroin addicts tend to be older people in their 40s – and yes, even they are living longer. But the message is finally  getting across: cirrhosis and addiction aren’t cool
However, we usually find a way of presenting health improvements negatively. It’s been pointed out that the drop in the heart death rate has left Scotland with the costly “burden” of caring for some 250,000 people living with heart problems. Well, as someone who is part of that burden, since I was stricken by the Scottish disease some years ago, I’d have to say that it’s a price worth paying. Most people with heart disease can still live perfectly normal and productive lives. It is only among the elderly that care costs seriously increase – but this again is a “problem” we should welcome.
Few things annoy me more than reading about the “ageing crisis” the “demographic time-bomb” and other complaints about the fact that we are all living longer. There was another eruption of demographic negativity last week following the latest census figures, which show that there are now more people living in Scotland who are over 65 than under 16. Oh dear – how will we cope with all these oldies sitting at home on their own eating cat food. Where are the young people to come from to pay their social costs through their taxes?
Well, one response is just not to get old. Look at the Rolling Stones who are still rocking into their seventies. Not only are people like Keith Richard a demonstration of just how resilient the human body can be even after a lifetime of abuse, they show that it is possible to keep working almost indefinitely. Our idea of work remains locked in the past. Age, and even physical infirmity, is no longer the barrier it used to be in the days when most people worked in physically demanding occupations.in future, most of us will be working on computers. 
As for the cost of caring for the infirm elderly – the perennial lament of public sector bureaucrats who, for some reason, never seem to see their generous pay and pensions as unaffordable “going forward” – well one solution may be at hand. The census surprised everyone by showing that Scotland’s population has actually risen by 5% in the last decade, after generations of decline. The fact that people are wanting to come here may be an answer to those commentators who like to present Scotland as a wasteland beyond hope. Immigrants tend to be young and have large families – producing in the process the workers who will pay the taxes of the future. That’s if they aren’t sent away again by the anti-immigration policies of a Conservative government.
So, be of good cheer. Living in Scotland is not a death sentence. In fact, some people quite like it here.

About @iainmacwhirter

I'm a columnist for the Herald. Author of "Road to Referendum" and "Disunited Kingdom". Was a BBC TV and radio presenter for 25 years - "Westminster Live" and "Holyrood Live" mainly. Spent time as columnist for The Observer, Guardian, New Statesman. Former Rector of Edinburgh University. Live in Edinburgh and spend a lot of time in the French Pyrenees. Will that do?


3 thoughts on “Scottish hearts are getting better. About time.

  1. Man learns, – when you stop hitting your head off a brick wall – your headaches also stopA popular theme running is that if you vote NO all you'll get is NOTHING. The same as always – steady as you go line – just ain't cutting the mustard no more and what's needed is change. These figures show people are changing and if there's a cost for that, let's keep it manageable. I'm pretty sure there's only one party, not only in Scotland, but the whole UK capable of doing that. As most people are now seeing – ain't we the lucky beggers!Have a good new year Iain.

    Posted by Barontorc | January 2, 2013, 11:52 am
  2. Good piece. I've been through the heart procedure experience. And I was fit. Road and mountain bike. Lifestyle is a major factor as you say. So is stress and probably more importantly, genetic history. This doesn't deter my dream of an Independent Scotland.

    Posted by Anonymous | January 2, 2013, 7:39 pm
  3. Interesting article. You never hear much about this sea change in life styles. It ought to be given far more publicity than it is.Thanks for cheering me up a bit. At least someone, somewhere is pointing out that it can get better, unlike a fellow journalist on the Scotsman.

    Posted by douglas clark | January 5, 2013, 12:51 pm

Twitter Updates

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 57,081 other followers

Follow Iain Macwhirter on WordPress.com



%d bloggers like this: